Share for friends:

With No One As Witness (2006)

With No One as Witness (2006)

Book Info

Genre
Rating
3.99 of 5 Votes: 3
Your rating
ISBN
0060545615 (ISBN13: 9780060545611)
Language
English
Publisher
harper

About book With No One As Witness (2006)

I have been a fan of the Thomas Lynley series from the beginning, reading them in order and loving each one. However, this one takes a plot twist that was a mistake, in my opinion. I was, quite honestly horrified and heart broken by what happened. I have continued to read the books after this one but I confess it is with less enthusiasm and I find I care less about the characters. It's as though since the author apparently doesn't care enough about the character to give them a life that is at least not miserable, why should I care? I don't understand why authors feel they must make their main characters miserable or make them the target of criminals. As if just because they are detectives, the whole world is out to get them. I quit reading the Kay Scarpetta series by Patricia Cornwell because it got so unbelievable that every criminal on the east coast even knows about, much less wants to kill the Virginia state medical examiner.I find the same disturbing trend in television detective series. Criminal Minds, CSI, NCIS, The Mentalist, etc. etc. etc. Either the main characters themselves or their spouses, girlfriends, boyfriends, etc. have all been targeted (stalked/murdered/tortured/etc.) by criminals. It's just too unbelievable. Ok, I'm done with my diatribe.

I read With No One As Witness because author Elizabeth George was a featured speaker at a 2006 Reader's Retreat I was scheduled to attend. I hadn't previously read anything she'd written, so selected her latest book to read before I attended the author's luncheon. I devoured it, caught up in the hunt through the least glamorous London neighborhoods for a ritualistic serial killer of young wayward boys. Full-bodied characters with believable flaws, multi-layered story, a one-two punch ending hooked me on George's writings. The story stands strongly on its own, even though it's over six books into a series of detective novels based on the same set of characters. As an avid mystery fan, I've found that the first few books from a serial author develop the characters, while later books often make assumptions about what the reader knows and leave the characters flat and stereotyped. In With No One As Witness, Elizabeth George did not fall into that trap, nor did she engage in tedious explanations of what had come before. I have since read all of the Inspector Lynley series that preceded With No One As Witness. It remains my favorite.

Do You like book With No One As Witness (2006)?

Was I the only one who wasn't shocked about Helen's death? Yes, it was brutal and senseless, but sadly, such is life. And as far as fictional characters go, Helen was one of the most shallow, one-dimensional annoying people you could imagine; I've found her obnoxious from day one and won't miss having her part of the stories any more. And speaking of story, this one was excellent, disturbing and captivating and one of my favourite of the series. I read it twice - once when it came out and then a
—Sibylle

I was exasperated by the monumental struggles with authority faced by Lynley, Havers and Nkata in this book. On top of their problems at work, too, Havers has to deal with an unpleasant situation at home, Nkata can't make any headway with Yasmin (and struggles with the recognition of his own weakness) and Lynley... well I won't go into that. All the personal drama is wrapped around the hunt for a serial killer who preys on those least likely to be missed. I enjoyed this book, in spite of the above-reference teeth-grinding exasperation. That's what life's like though, isn't it? Good people do have to struggle, just as much as the rest of us. The ending was devastating. Yeah, they caught the killer, but so what? I knew bad stuff was coming and had guessed who would be the victim, but it was still deeply wrenching and very emotional. A good book, well-written. I'll be reading "What Came Before He Shot Her" next, to learn more about the events leading up to the ending of this book, and look forward to finding out what happens to our favorite characters as they move forward.
—Chris

I know I wrote a review for this some time ago and I'm disappointed the system seems to have blipped said review into oblivion..... As with almost all George's books, I loved this one and was so dumbstruck and awed and distressed by the ending that I could not read the sequel to this particular story - 'What Happened Before He Shot Her'..... still haven't managed to get to it although I've read 'Color of Blood' I think it's called - the one that came after "What Happened..." ..... anyway.... I'll enthusiastically awaiting the new one, which I've requested from the library and should be coming my way in a week or so..... YAY!!! FOr the future reader's FYI, there is a sequence to all her books -not just which was written and published first, but the story line of Inspector Linley and his friends and colleagues..... which actually starts with 'A Suitable Vengence'. George is a brilliant writer of crime. Hope you all enjoy!
—Sandy

download or read online

Read Online

Write Review

(Review will shown on site after approval)

Other books by author Elizabeth George

Other books in series Inspector Lynley

Other books in category Fiction