Share for friends:

The Sisters Mortland (2007)

The Sisters Mortland (2007)

Book Info

Author
Genre
Rating
3.55 of 5 Votes: 1
Your rating
ISBN
0446696013 (ISBN13: 9780446696012)
Language
English
Publisher
grand central publishing

About book The Sisters Mortland (2007)

I wanted to really love this book. The book summary set the stage for a novel I would really enjoy, alluding to a dark family tragedy that compounds already complicated relationships. I expected a careful interweaving of events and people - a book that was haunting in its complexity, a bit like Ethan Frome. Instead, I felt that it read more like a sensational tabloid that undermined its own main characters (how could we like them when they treated each other - and themselves - so horribly?) and provided no real insight as to why the characters acted the way they did. Instead of closely examining the tragedy and carefully unfolding its resulting effects on the Mortland family and friends, the reader experiences the tragedy and then is thrown decades into the future. From this future space, we are expected to understand why all of the characters (most of which were hard to like in the first place) have turned into monsters, with only vague allusions to the accident and why it occurred. The reader never fully understands (as the characters don't) why the accident happened - but that wouldn't be important if we came to an ultimate understanding of the characters and their motivations. For such a vague, sad book, the characters are given only brief (and unrealistic) redemption in the end - but for me it couldn't save the story.

I'd give it two & a half stars. A decent way to waste some time & a good airplane read, which is exactly where I read the first half of it. It starts out really well. The first part is narrated by Maisie, who at first glance seems to be an overly precocious 13 year old girl - but you later find she's mildly autistic. I found her narration intriguing - I liked the setting in the old Suffolk abbey - the 3 sisters - the gypsies - the Wild Boy in the Window - so much more could have been done with this! This is where a better writer would have created more interesting and less stereotypical characters, and would have kept the story moving a bit more quickly - I got bored during the middle part of the book. It was predictable to me that the oldest sister grows up to be a cold yet successful Martha Stewart type. And of course the middle sister goes through hard times & becomes a Mercy Corps type. And of course the Wild Boy turns to alcohol & drugs after his initial success & yet winds up a hero of sorts. The plot is more "soap opera" than mystery. There's a few surprises & an ambiguous ending - which is a good thing - but overall, this was slightly unsatisfying.

Do You like book The Sisters Mortland (2007)?

Every character in this book is keeping secrets. Twenty years after tragedy hits the Mortland family, the truth about the accident, and all the family secrets, start to unravel, almost to the point that the reader feels out of control. When I started this book i felt I had stepped into a Jane Austen novel. It was interesting enough, but then this pleasant story slowly started taking some dark turns, and didn't stop until the whole thing was over. I believe my mouth was a gap when I finished. While others may disagree, I thought Beauman was brilliant
—Beth

One of the best choices I have ever made in the "bought it randomly because it was a bargain book and looked intriguing" category. The first portion is set in 1967 narrated by a 13 year old girl, while the rest of the book is set 20+ years later as the characters grapple with unravelling the events of that ultimately tragic summer. Interesting character studies and suspenseful though not quite a mystery. Also randomly this is about the 5th book I have read this year set in part in the decaying estate of a once wealthy British family, although this one was perhaps a little less gothic than the rest.
—Jennifer

Where do I join the Sally Beauman fanclub? I didn't know her 2 months ago and now this is the second book by her I've read (first was 'The Visitors') and both get 5 stars from me. How do I love Sally? Let me count the ways:1. She can write like nobody's business (ahem-to coin a phrase)2. She plots her stories well with complex characters and intricate detail3. You can take the story at face value, but her themes revolve around the bigger picture of humanities brilliance, flaws and emotions4. Twice now, I have found her stories to be unpredictable; in other words, I could NOT foresee what was going to happen or how a situation would resolve itself5. She takes the time to build up the momentum by conscientiously and lavishly describing the characters and setting; I feel like I am part of the story by the time it starts "cooking"This story of 3 sisters and 3 men is very English but not conventional. A few of the characters take a turn as narrator and I found it uniquely moving. I think this is Ms. Beauman's true talent...she creates characters that I, for one, feel strong emotions. I would also characterize her writing as especially enjoyable for those of us who enjoy the journey and aren't intently focused on the destination. I can hardly wait to read another one of her books.
—Randee

download or read online

Read Online

Write Review

(Review will shown on site after approval)

Other books by author Sally Beauman

Other books in category Fantasy