Share for friends:

The Hamilton Case (2005)

The Hamilton Case (2005)

Book Info

Rating
3.12 of 5 Votes: 3
Your rating
ISBN
0316010812 (ISBN13: 9780316010818)
Language
English
Publisher
back bay books

About book The Hamilton Case (2005)

De Kretser wrote a biting critique on the effects of colonial rule on her native Sri Lanka in this novel. She begins with an excerpt from the memoirs of a Sinhalese lawyer, who identifies so strongly with the Brits that he adopts their love of law, their mannerisms, and their passions for crime fiction. The highlight of Obeysekere's career comes when he solves The Hamilton Case, accusing a white British citizen of killing another British tea planter. This was an audacious accusation that had long-lasting implications on Obey's career and self-identity. His big rival, "Jungle Jaya" is a nationalist, a politician who gains fame for his populism even while he seems to instigate an ethnic war between the Sinhalese and the Tamils following emancipation from the British. Jaya is briefly married to Obey's sister, Claudia, a fragile character who is implicated in several mysterious family tragedies. While the reader never gets any concrete answers about any of the mysteries she creates, she makes it perfectly clear that the real criminal was the British Empire. The Empire, she argues, forced people to play ill-fitting roles that created a corrupt, diseased society. De Kretser's story was enjoyable overall but not terribly original. Aspects of the Obeyskere's family unravelling reminded me of Rushdie's Shame with her use of magical realism and her focus on the family's dysfunctionality. The themes were much like any post-colonial novel. Her narrative structure was also a little confusing to me. After opening the book with Obey's memoirs, she shifts to a third person perspective, which took a while for me to catch up to, and then finishes with a letter from a previously minor character. I think I would have preferred a more traditional mystery with a Sri Lankan Sherlock Holmes that critiqued colonialism by gently mocking those that believed in it so heartily.

My problem with The Hamilton Case is the way it is marketed. I should know by now not to trust a book by its blurb. When I picked it up I was somewhat excited to be informed that I would be reading about an intriguing murder mystery set in late colonial Ceylon. I was hooked for the first hundred pages or so, reading the first-person narrative of the main protagonist Sam Obeysekere. He's an interesting and likable character and I thought it to be a build up of sorts. Then, shortly after his narrative ended and the second part of the book began I started wading through the murky depths of a much different story - one about family, betrayal and the effect colonialism had on them. Chapters began to merge into one another with no indication that one was ending other than a paragraph space. I think there were about fifty pages or more of Sam's mother and her daily rituals as a lonely widower in a rural home. I wasn't digging it. I have no problem with reading about these themes. Some of them were interesting to be touched on but it takes getting halfway through the book to realize that The Hamilton Case, the actual murder in which the book is named after is just a sub-plot at best. You almost get the feeling that de Kretser has to remind herself to mention it at times as she takes you deeper into the family estrangements and political drama the book truly is trying to speak about. Maybe I just didn't get it and probably wont. I'm not saying the themes are irrelevant. Reading about Sri Lanka in its final days of British rule were very interesting and de Kretser is a gifted writer. All I'm saying is don't tell me rack of lamb is on the menu if all I'm doing is walking into a soup kitchen.

Do You like book The Hamilton Case (2005)?

Where to begin? Changing the cover of this book to the above, did not make this book any more appealing.I read about 225 pages, and was still clueless-the character of Sam was downright condescending and arrogant-along with the handful of annoying and strange characters. Who are these people? what relevance do any of these chapters have to each other??The synopsis has NOTHING to do with the book.Skip it...completely confusing and unlikable. I gave up, and I never give up on a book unless its absolutely awful.
—Michelle

A lot of abuse takes place in this book. Of women by men, children by adults, workers by overseers, the powerful vs the powerless becomes analogous to colonialism. However, the protagonist, a Sri Lankan named Sam, is someone who has done well out of colonial rule; his parents are landowners, he is Oxford educated, but when Ceylon becomes Sri Lanka, he becomes obsolete.The beautiful descriptions and lush atmosphere belie a corrupt society. There are two mysteries central to the plot: who killed the British tea-planter, Hamilton, a case Sam claims to have solved in his capacity as an Agatha Christie reading lawyer, and whether, as a child, Sam killed his baby brother and abused his sister. We never really find out.De Kretser chooses to narrate most of the book in the third person so that she can easily jump from Sam to his wife, his son, his mother, his mother's servant and back again, but it's a pity that she didn't stay with the first person unreliable narrator who tells the early part of the story. Sam thinks he understands, but he doesn't always see the truth, he thinks he's telling us what happended, but he keeps much concealed - he's the perfect chronicler for a book about colonialism.
—Rachel Stevenson

This is not a fast paced mystery book but it's a book that is to be savored. It's lush, layered and reveals itself bit by delicious bit like the jungles of Sri Lanka, the country where the story is set. The story is set in Sri Lanka pre-WWII at a time when the British colonial influence is very strong. The main character is English in all but appearance. He is an upper class Sri Lankan educated in England. He returns to Sri Lanka to practice law and is quite good at it. His involvement in a famous murder, the Hamilton Case, is at the core of the story and transforms him at a time Sri Lanka is undergoing radical transformation from colonialism to self-determination. His delicate sister and their flamboyant beautiful mother are the other main characters. I thoroughly enjoyed the book. It's something you can read more than once for the author just has a way with words. I just love the way she writes. It's gorgeous if you can call writing gorgeous. Her words evoke images that are very powerful. You learn so much about colonialism and its effects, Sri Lanka, life in a hot tropical climate, etc.
—Bookfanatic

download or read online

Read Online

Write Review

(Review will shown on site after approval)

Other books in category Young Adult Fantasy & Science Fiction