I was so excited to discover the existence of this book after reading So Much To Tell You. I was pretty blown away by that one, so I was thrilled to know there was a companion novel which, according to Wikipedia, would fill in the gaps and detail the aftermath of the first book. Told from Lisa’s point of view, we get a little insight into how she and the other girls view Marina, the troubled protagonist of So Much To Tell You, but overall the focus is on Lisa’s own life. Which makes sense, seeing as how this is her “journal” and all. Considering the journals were a class project it was understandable that it would be used as a narrative device once again here. But while it worked incredibly effectively for Marina, I found Lisa’s journal quite ordinary. Perhaps it’s unfair to compare them, but being companion novels, it’s kind of impossible not to. The characters and events are largely the same, it’s only the perspective that changes.I just didn’t connect with Lisa emotionally and wasn’t as invested in her story. The central “mystery” wasn’t as compelling as it was in the first novel, and it was all a bit predictable. Plus I didn’t get anywhere near as much insight into the events left out of Marina’s journal as I was hoping to. And while I’ve noted that So Much To Tell You is the type of YA novel that would appeal to readers of any age, I really don’t think Take My Word For It has the kind of cross-over factor that would make it of interest to anyone who isn’t a teen – and probably a young one at that. There is some beautiful writing, but overall it’s quite a bland book.
Re-read November 24-25, 2011, while in Den Haag. I kind of had to go and re-read it since I'd just rediscovered the amazingness of So Much to Tell You! (And this was the one with the head of the schoolgirls rowing regatta mentioned. And MLC as well.) Overall though, while Lisa's story certainly is interesting, it's not as engaging and perfect as Marina's. I like seeing the "other" side of So Much To Tell You, but in a way I prefer to only see Lisa from the outside, rather than having all of her mystery taken away. It's nice to know, but you don't really NEED to... if that makes sense. I guess we also don't find out as much as we could have found out. The book needed to be longer and a bit more in-depth I think.
