Share for friends:

Salamander (2002)

Salamander (2002)

Book Info

Rating
3.69 of 5 Votes: 1
Your rating
ISBN
0743444159 (ISBN13: 9780743444156)
Language
English
Publisher
washington square press

About book Salamander (2002)

Never before for me has a book that was demonstrating such glorious promise suddenly turned out to be crap. It built me up only to deliver a swift kick to the groin of my imagination when I least expected it. Sneaky.One of the first things that I noticed (and loved) about this book, apart from the beautiful artwork on the cover, was the impressively fast pace. The first half of the book doesn't get bogged down in a lot of flowery language or unnecessary fluff, it gets straight into the story and I find this very refreshing in any book, especially a fantasy book, however it was too good to last.The first half of the story seems a unique cross between Dracula, Gormengast and the classic 80's film Labyrinth. Nicholas Flood, a young English printer is commissioned by a strange and eccentric Slovakian Count whose huge castle is a maze of puzzles, revolving walls and machines in human likeness to create an 'infinite' book with no beginning and no end. An intriguing idea made all the more interesting by the bizarre castle and the love interest with the Counts beautiful daughter Irena. The book is ticking along nicely, the characters are interesting as is the story then suddenly without warning the book flies off into another time and place leaving the reader bewildered and lost.I was horribly shocked to realise suddenly that all the characters I had grown to love in the first half of the book were suddenly gone! Flood is imprisoned by the count in the castles dungeon and left to die. Time leaps forward 12 years before Flood escapes!This was a bold step by the author and a big gamble. Oh how I wish I could say it worked well and added a new dimension to the book but alas it did not. It horrified and confused me. The next thing I know a new, weaker character is introduced out of the blue, an old character returns completely changed and suddenly not so likeable, the old castle is gone so is the count and countess. The story zooms off around the world leaving me struggling to keep up. The fast past of the book remained but the clear coherent story vanished into thin air (like most of the characters) in parts the book descends into poetic nonsense (which really infuriated me because the lack of this was what I loved about the first part!) but the story itself built up from the beginning is lost in this new adventure the new characters embark on. I found I quickly lost interest and the overwhelming disappointment ruined the story for me. I almost felt the author got bored with the castle and story of the first half of the book and suddenly desired a change, or perhaps he was trying to write his own 'infinite' book but I'm afraid all he did was try too hard. This stands out to me like a sore thumb. It really is a terrible shame because I loved the first half and could have easily read another 200 pages or so of that story.

I wanted to like this book much more than I actually did, as the story had the potential to be so good. I liked the way that the setting was just far enough removed from the recognisable historical past that it feels uncanny and strange rather than totally different; the ideas the novel has about books are intriguing and enjoyable; and some of the descriptive passages are excellent. Unfortunately, it just didn't quite live up to the expectations of the blurb or of the beginning of the book.The book essentially has two plots: the first of the mad mechanical castle and its inhabitants and the second of the journey around the world in quest of the components for the infinite book. Both would have been quite good on their own, but they did not seem to be particularly well meshed together and for most of the book they felt entirely separate. I would rather that both sections had been fleshed out a bit and more interwoven with each other to create a longer book. As it stands, both stories feel skimmed over at times and neither is concluded in as satisfactory a manner as I feel it should be.I also found the lack of quotation marks very distracting. Direct speech was indicated with dashes and came across more like reported speech, a device which was used all too often in any case. The result of this was that I often found the characters to be remote and unreal. I wish this book had been better.

Do You like book Salamander (2002)?

It's hard to know what to make of Thomas Wharton's Salamander. Even two days after I finished reading it, it's still in my brain. It's probably a good thing I was in a hotel that was stingy about Internet, or I would have rushed out a review right away. Perhaps the only definitive thing I can say about Salamander is that it is a that might have the power to turn non-readers into bibliophiles with its blend of fairy tale, high adventure, philosophy, and love...Read the rest of my review at Summer Reading Project.
—Annie

When his 18-year-old son dies mysteriously in battle, a Slovakian Count retires from the field and returns home to indulge his love of puzzles. He designs his castle so that walls continually appear and disappear, furniture is on tracks and moves to different places, and bookshelves descend from the ceiling or rise, phoenix-like, from the floor. While cataloging a new set of books, the Count’s daughter finds one that has been created to be a riddle. Her father is intrigued and invites the printer, a young Londoner named Nicholas Flood, to the castle to discuss a commission: an infinite book. Nicholas accepts the commission and the rest of the book is devoted to his quest to fulfill his commission. The road to Flood’s eventual fate does not run smoothly, and before the journey is over we’ve traveled the world and met a family of tumblers, a Sultan who wishes to die, a printing press that sets its own type, a lady pirate, and scores of other memorable characters. Salamander is a quest book: everybody is looking for something, both physically and emotionally. It’s amazing that Wharton manages to weave all of their diverse searches into the one Grand Search: the never-ending book. It’s that one goal that brings all of the characters together, and that occasionally tears them apart. I’ll admit, I’m biased; I love books, and the descriptions of the various papers and inks and the workings of the printing press were fascinating. But the wonderful thing is that all of that detail isn’t just sitting there, waiting for the book geek to stroll by. The search for all of the physical trappings of the infinite book gives us a touchstone for all of the characters: WHY someone is searching for the perfect paper is just as important as how the search is conducted, or where the search leads. Wharton has given us a gift: a magical, mysterious, marvel of book. The characters are strange, yet believable. The story takes many odd twists and turns and never ends up quite where you expect it to. The narrative flows like spilled ink, covering everything and forcing the reader into some unexpected corners. Mr. Wharton cleverly sets the reader on just as much of a quest as the characters are on; the reader who perseveres will be greatly rewarded.
—Peggy

I felt a bit heartless giving this book 1 star, so I wanted to supplement with a review. I read Salamander many years ago. I was 14 or 15, I think, and I picked it out for the title and cover, then was enchanted by the synopsis. It started out incredibly well, and I was gearing up to fall hopelessly in love with this book that had amazing potential. But as I read on, the story fell so short of my expectations, it actually broke my heart. I think that's my primary reason for giving Salamander such a low rating--for breaking my heart. Quite unfair of me, to be honest, because the first half of the book alone deserves 5 stars. To this day, 7 or 8 years later, I still taste bitter regret when I remember the great promise this book had. It's like thinking you've found the love of your life, then suddenly being horrifically disappointed.But still I hope.Through all the bookshelf cleanings I've done over the years, Salamander has stayed. All those times, I would look at it wistfully and think, I want to try again, like an ex-lover you want to give a second chance. Maybe this will be the year that I reread Salamander and, with the wisdom of the last 8 years, love it. All of it. Or maybe this will be the year that I reread Salamander and be disappointed all over again. If the latter, I hope that the heartbreak, the second time around, will allow me to finally move on, mark the book as a dud, and donate it to the library.[Second rating and review forthcoming.]
—Laraine

download or read online

Read Online

Write Review

(Review will shown on site after approval)

Other books by author Thomas Wharton

Other books in category Young Adult Fiction