While better than the first in this series, this book was still formulaic and easy to figure out. It was enjoyable mostly for the characters--I like Miss Unwin and I liked Euphemia "Phemy" Pastell very much. And even knowing who the killer is, there is still suspense because it seems impossible that they will be uncovered with enough time to spare (though of course, you know that somehow it will work out). I found it a bit repetitive but overall a fun read. Not a keeper, but a nice way to pass a dreary autumn day.