Share for friends:

Cry Rape: The True Story Of One Woman's Harrowing Quest For Justice (2006)

Cry Rape: The True Story of One Woman's Harrowing Quest for Justice (2006)

Book Info

Author
Genre
Rating
4.04 of 5 Votes: 5
Your rating
ISBN
0299219607 (ISBN13: 9780299219604)
Language
English
Publisher
university of wisconsin press

About book Cry Rape: The True Story Of One Woman's Harrowing Quest For Justice (2006)

I came away from this book troubled deeply in mind and soul. It speaks to so, so many issues that a lot of us would rather leave alone.This is the horrific story of a visually impaired woman who is raped by a knife-wielding intruder and essentially raped again by law-enforcement authorities who carelessly opened her life to all kinds of public scrutiny as they sought to discredit her claims. Their efforts at discrediting the woman were methodical and stunning in their ruthlessness and what appeared to me to be careless reckless disregard for the truth. This is also a classic case of those in authority seeking to take out their vengeance on a reporter who simply sought to tell a story that desperately needed to be told.This book tacitly raises questions about blindness and credibility in the eyes of sighted law enforcement and medical people. It almost seemed as though some of them couldn’t get their heads around the idea that a visually impaired person would be able to credibly contribute to a discussion about events that happened to her. The woman clearly had no credibility with many of them, and when she questioned their credibility, they lashed out in ways that were stunning indeed.To his credit, the author looks unflinchingly at both sides of this. He isn’t afraid to write about ways in which the woman may have exercised errors in judgment, not during the rape so much as in later events. But throughout, he is sympathetic, clearly explaining how someone in her position might arrive at the same judgment calls she made.Additionally, the author covers the rape without going into gratuitous detail in an attempt to needlessly titillate. He gives you the information you need without inappropriately overloading you, but nor does he minimize the event by shrugging it off her implicitly questioning whether it was as bad as the visually impaired woman claimed.At one point, in desperation, the woman appears to back down in an attempt to end an abrasive interview with a detective who questioned the veracity of her story almost immediately. The author attributes the woman’s backing down as a byproduct of a dysfunctional family background. I suspect the vision loss thing came into play here, too, but he doesn’t seem to explore that as one of the reasons for her willingness to at least temporarily walk back her story.I got the strongest impression from this author that no amount of clear concise communication would have tilted the investigating detective’s perspective from one of incredulity to one of belief. That said, he doesn’t write this as if it were some shrill crusade to gallantly help the poor blind woman. Instead, he outlines the case and the steps taken to get justice in the case. He gives credit to those who changed their positions on the case and ultimately came around to the woman’s perspective. But through it all, you are left shaking your head in wonder at the seemingly impenetrable ignorance that prevented the investigation and ultimate conviction of a rapist to occur relatively quickly. Rather, this became a protracted battle in which a woman sought to reclaim her life and reputation while medical and law-enforcement officials in a seemingly enlightened major American city in the Midwest did everything they could to minimize her efforts at justice. The author aptly points out that of the words “criminal justice system,” the word that deserves the most emphasis is “system.” There are issues the book simply can’t answer—issues that are beyond its scope—about blindness and power and the issue of whether a blind woman is more likely to be raped than her sighted counterpart because of the blindness itself. It seemed, based on what I read here, that even some women turned against this particular victim, warning her that falsifying a rape charge would make things just that much harder for the next person who brought similar charges.I don’t do true crime books often; I enjoy them, but usually in small doses and with plenty of time between them. This book more than filled my quota for a while. But it left me with much to think about and much over which to be troubled.

Do You like book Cry Rape: The True Story Of One Woman's Harrowing Quest For Justice (2006)?

Unfortunately, a disabled woman who is sexually assaulted is not a new story. It's also not news that sexual assault victims are often victimized by the same system that is supposed to help them. In Cry Rape, Bill Lueders shows how the following factors created a "perfect storm", making a living Hell for one rape victim: a blind woman bearing the scars of childhood abuse, an inexperienced police investigator, poor supervision, bad policies, biases towards the mentally ill, lack of understanding of sexual assault, "nearsighted" judges, and a police department that will go to any lengths (or lows)to be right. BTW, this tragedy occurred in modern-day Madison, WI, a city blindsided by its own hubris and its delusions of being a quasi-utopia. The book, which was based on a series of articles Lueders wrote for The Isthmus (a local paper) represents investigative journalism at its finest. Most impressive is the courage of Patty, the victim, who withstood unconscionable mistreatment by the "justice" system for six years, in the process losing her credibility, her business, and a lot of money, but not her determination to bring her attacker to justice.
—Aimee

download or read online

Read Online

Write Review

(Review will shown on site after approval)

Other books in category Fiction