Share for friends:

Anglo-Saxon Attitudes (1994)

Anglo-Saxon Attitudes (1994)

Book Info

Author
Genre
Rating
3.63 of 5 Votes: 2
Your rating
ISBN
0140174249 (ISBN13: 9780140174243)
Language
English
Publisher
penguin

About book Anglo-Saxon Attitudes (1994)

It is clear that the author had big ambitions for this book. One sign is the cast list at the beginning. There are numerous references to the excavation at Melpham, and the lengthy appendix on this subject must mean it is very important. Right? So it's strange to find it isn't. The pagan artefact found in the Christian tomb had either been placed there at the time or later. It turns out to have been later, as the joke of an embittered individual. But really, all this creaking apparatus is of no real significance. What signifies are the attitudes adopted towards the find in the burial, particularly that of Gerald, Professor Middleton. He has suspected the truth for years and done nothing about it. It is amusing to note the discussion concerning whether the inclusion of a pagan artefact in the tomb of a Christian churchman might be considered 'un-English'. This is very odd indeed because the real question, surely, is whether it is un-Christian. And this is just one of many instances where the author's obsession with England and the English make the book tedious. It comes up time and again in unexpected, unjustified and uninteresting ways. For example, take the first two pages referring to John Middleton, who clearly writes for a national paper: 'in this overgoverned England of ours', 'everyone of us in England today,' ' a friend of England.' And as the book starts, so it continues. Chapter Two (starting page 233) is an astonishing assault on the un-english reader: 'so very English', 'beloved of his English colleagues', 'I'm very English', 'three elderly English scholars with no real communion of feeling except their nationality', (good one that, when there is no such thing as English nationality), 'it's my chauvinistic pride as an Englishman'. You can say that again, Angus.It's really quite sad when you consider the good people England has produced who didn't feel impelled to go on like this. The Angles and the Saxons certainly didn't.The flip side of this rabid pro-Englishness may be found in some of the other characters. Gerald's wife is something of a basket case so she isn't English, she's Danish. More seriously, John Middleton is gay and he has a gay friend, Larrie, who is not only gay but exceedingly unpleasant and manipulative.. Guess what? He's Irish. The author even has him say 'sure' at one point. The character of Yves Houdet is, if anything, even worse, and as we can tell by the name, he's about as un-English as you can get. Gerald: 'he detested the flashy smartness of such Latin womanizers.' (p238). I get the impression Angus had little idea of the Scots, but he still finds room for a quick stereotype: 'Now little Hilda Ferguson, fiercely Scots with her flaming red hair and shrill soap-box voice, rose to express her agreement . . . ' page 41. Though she does come up with the first chapter of the History he's editing and it looked 'most interesting' (p273). Needless to say it concerns England, namely, 'the influence of the Crusades on English social life.' So we subtract the Irish, the Latins, the Scots, the Danes, the Welsh don't exist – and what are we are left with? The English!And what sort of a person is this Gerald anyway? He runs a wife and a mistress for many years, so he's really fastidious. Doesn't get round to asking his wife till at least twenty years after the event what really occurred when his daughter Kay's hand got burned! But to cut to the important things: 'Despite his English ironic temperament, he had not got the usual English worship of the sense of the ridiculous.' (p267).There is also some reason to believe that English social class divisions were very important to Angus, hence the music hall depictions of Mrs Salad, Vin Salad, and Frank Rammage. And there are other characters in this category.So is the book any good? It is at its best where it deals with the relationships between the main characters, by which I mean the main middle and upper class characters. The tensions between John and Robin Middleton, and Kay of the damaged hand and her husband Donald – all that is quite good and keeps the reader's interest. Though I did feel that Dollie Portway, Gerald's ex-mistress, was a bit over the top in the jolly-hockey-sticks stakes.But whatever the inflated machinery Wilson provides to support the book, it amounts to a lot less than he thought.

I suspect this one will gain on a second reading--it's hard for me, a late twentieth century, transplanted Australian, to really get the class issues that Wilson is, I'm pretty sure, out to examine. It's funny in places, in a very English/ironic way, and the characters are fantastic. There's not really any story, which I don't mind. And yet somehow it didn't grab me. Partly, I suspect, this is because of the ludicrously long chapters (this goes double for those particularly intellectual authors who refuse to put in any chapter breaks at all, or paragraph breaks, because, like, that would totally restrict the free-ranging wildebeest that is their genius); partly because so much of the book seems so irrelevant until very, very late; partly because I was expecting something else. So obviously I am ambivalent. The introduction by Jane Smiley is much better than the usual NYRB introduction: she suggests that Wilson was trying to write a nineteenth century novel, which makes good sense of what he has done; and she points out, accurately, that many of the class references will fly over readers' heads.

Do You like book Anglo-Saxon Attitudes (1994)?

Anthony Burgess blurbed that this was one of the five greatest novels of the [20th] century! I didn't see it, myself.I had no idea what the book was about when I bought it. I was sucked in by that NYRB cover and John Tenniel's delightful Through the Looking Glass illustration. Once inside, I was pleased to find that the story took place within academia's sordid walls and involved an archeological excavation - a priapic wooden fertility idol is found in the tomb of a 7th century Christian bishop, but at the end of the book's first section we find out the idol is a hoax, placed there by an acquaintance of the protagonist, Gerald Middleton. Except this turns out not to take up huge amounts of the novel. Instead, we're led through endless set pieces and conversations involving the extended Middleton family and their mistresses, acquaintances, and a bevy of low class homosexual men. So really this ends up being a comic novel about a large, dysfunctional family. It was hard to get through. I liked the font, but the font was tiny. 350 pages seemed more like 500 pages. Out of nearly 50 characters, there were maybe one or two I found likable. I know this isn't supposed to matter. It's the rube's way of reading literature! But don't you have to find something to grasp onto, if the other elements of the novel are failing to satisfy?There was one character I found delightful. His name is Armand Sarthe and he's introduced with about 5% of the book left. Our protagonist, Gerald Middleton, is an upper class academic. At a party thrown by his French daughter-in-law Marie-Hélène, Gerald has M. Sarthe, a man who writes distinctly less scholarly books, foisted upon him:As he took a glass of champagne from one of the hired waiters, he saw with horror that Marie-Hélène was leading a tall, grey-haired Frenchman towards him. It was as he feared, the distinguished author of Les causes célèbres du moyen âge, Armand Sarthe. Oh well, he thought, the chap must be a cynical journalist who's written the stuff for money; he may well be quite a pleasant fellow in real life. But when Marie-Hélène moved away in grave deference to the esoteric bonds of scholarship that united them, M. Sarthe's first words were not promising.'Woman,' he said, and he waved his hand towards Marie-Hélène's sharp shoulder-blades protruding uglily above the flowing folds of her crimson gown, 'defies the historian's art. We can catch her differences, the change in her art. We can catch for a moment the turn of Aspasia's head as she delights Pericles with her wit. We can bring to life again the harsh note in Xanthippe's scolding voice. We can turn with horror from the cruelty in Messalina's eyes or with shame for ourselves from the innocent love with which Heloise looks at her lover. We can stand with the Maid as she scorns her judges. But the essential woman - the woman that was there in the caves at Lascaux and is here in this room today - eludes us. Do you agree?'Gerald had some difficulty in following the rapid French, so he contented himself by saying 'Yes.'Famed Brit Webster Groves, Missouri native Jane Smiley's introduction is fairly useless, unless you count the insult whereby American readers are let off the hook: "...Americans may be forgiven if they don't quite understand what everything in Anglo-Saxon Attitudes means, because it is full of behavior codes and language codes, nuances in attitudes and relationships that are perplexing, and even invisible, to outsiders." Okay, well, that must explain it all.
—Lobstergirl

Wilson, Angus. ANGLO-SAXON ATTITUDES. (1956). *****. tThis is a marvelous novel, which, in spite of my high rating, will certainly not be to everyone’s taste. The story is set, primarily, in England, between the two wars – although the focus of the story occurred during an archeological dig in the years 1912-1914 by Professor Stokesay, Regius Professor of English History, and an authority on the 7th century. It was during his discovery and excavation of what was found to be the tomb of Bishop Eorwald, a 7th century Christian missionary at the court of Aldbert of the East Folk, that a pagan idol was found among the relics. What Professor Stokesay did not know was that this piece was surrepticiously placed in the tomb by his son Gilbert as a joke. The discovery of the object, however, turned the world of English historians on its collective ear and was the basis of a new thesis that the respected bishop had managed to hang on to some of the extant pagan beliefs in England – even to his death. How all of this plays out is the plot of the novel – primarily as tracked by Professor Gerald Middleton, a Professor Emeritus of early medieval hi9story and a former pupil of Professor Stokesay. This is a slow dense read, but one I found rewarding. Highly recommended.
—Tony

This was such an immense fun! It took me some time to warm up to the story, because there seemed to be a tad too many characters and I couldn't tell where it was going... But then! I don't remember when I started to like it, but it might have had something to do with the appearance of Vin and his set. I liked them a lot, the lowlifes! Especially Frank.Inge was also fun to read about, but she was scary, even more than the horrible Alice or what was his name, Ives? Now that dude was evil! But fun. They were all evil and fun. I sort of rooted for Gerard, unusual for me - I usually end up disliking main characters.So why 4 stars and not 5? Oh. I got some anti-foreigner and anti-working class (okay maybe not, but basically if you aren't at a certain level of income and education, you simply can't be worth much; you may possess a "reptilian intelligence". I liked it! Hah! Sounds cool, to have something reptilian) vibes. Also, I would have liked to see more about Larry and John's ill-fated (?) romance. It got resolved a bit too abruptly for such an elaborate build-up. I anticipated much more waves...
—Tocotin

download or read online

Read Online

Write Review

(Review will shown on site after approval)

Other books by author Angus Wilson

Other books in category Fiction