About book A Gentleman Undone. Cecilia Grant (2012)
A Gentleman Undone is one of the best capital-R Romance novels I've ever read. I'm a little new to the genre (although quickly making up for lost time as my "Read 100 Books in 2014" Challenge is evolving into a "Read 100 Romance Novels in 2014" Challenge) so I am by no means an expert, but A Gentleman Undone stands out to me as an exceptional example of the genre. The writing is simply wonderful. It's smart, it's thoughtful, it "shows not tells," it employs some familiar Regency Romance tropes (a duel, a country house party, card games, wagers gone wrong) in fresh, compelling ways. The book is well-plotted and paced, and although it takes a few chapters to warm to the MCs -- both of whom are working through some horrific trauma -- the investment is worth it. Once you grow to care for them, you can't help but root for their success against seemingly insurmountable odds.Both MCs are emotionally wounded and it makes for a much more compelling plot than a typical Romance read where the troubled heroine or brooding hero is soothed and healed through the power of a pure, compassionate love. Grant gets elbow deep in the notion that you have to go straight to the eye of the hurricane for forgiveness and absolution. When these two tortured souls get together, it's magic.There's lots of sparky sex scenes and flirtatious banter but the physical aspects of the romance are not all-encompassing. There is a plot, and a good one, it's not just a fluffy Regency backdrop for the MCs to go from one tryst to the next.Finally, the reader gets to spend more time with the remarkable Blackshear siblings, who we met in A Lady Awakened but didn't get to know nearly well enough. Even though they are tertiary characters at best, Grant is a capable writer who packs a powerful punch with just a few scenes -- we learn so much about their family dynamic and their place in their society in such a short time. It's just really well-done. This is the kind of capital-R Romance novel I would recommend to readers who like historical fiction but aren't really in the mood for an outright bodice ripper. I absolutely loved Grant’s first book A Lady Awakened, and she doesn't disappoint in this book either. I don’t quite remember the love scenes being quite that explicit in her first book. But perhaps it has to do with the fact that the female lead in this book is a courtesan, who was previously employed as a prostitute. The story starts in 1815, with Will Blackshear trying to get medical attention for one of his men, Talbot, who was injured at the battle of Waterloo. While Will thought that he was doing the right thing by bring the injured man to the hospital, he may have in fact hastened the man’s death. Will has since sold his commission in the army is now back in London, and needs money to execute a plan. We encounter Will at a gentleman’s club, where numerous men have brought their mistresses. Will is intrigued by one in particular, Lydia Slaughter, and he is not sure why. Will is even more intrigued when she is able to fleece him out of a sizable amount of money, which he needs to execute his plan. The next time they meet, he demands that she return his money. Lydia refuses, seeing that she has a plan that needs money as well. That same night while playing cards, Lydia arranges for Will to win back the exact amount she fleeced him. It turns out that Lydia had a head for numbers and uses that to her advantage while playing cards. It dawns on Lydia, that Will and she could both win the amount of money that they need, if they work together. This of course entails them spending a lot of time together and the attraction between them builds. There are many reasons why I enjoyed this book. Cecilia Grant has a really different take on the historical romance genre. All of Grant’s female characters are incredibly intelligent, perhaps even smarter than her male leads. Oftentimes it is the female lead that actual teaches the men a few things. In "A Lady Awakened", Martha teaches Theo about how to manage an estate. Here in A Gentleman Undone Lydia teaches Will how to count cards and cannot understand why he has difficulty with her counting system. Another aspect of Lydia which I liked was the fact that she was comfortable with her sexuality. She truly enjoys having sex, and took some pride in the fact that she was good in bed. However, I do think that because of what happened to Lydia, to land her in a brothel in the first place, that there is an aspect of punishment in the act of sex for her.Will, in many ways is much more of a typical leading man. He is the war hero who comes home with a promise made to a man in his last few minutes of life. But what makes Will’s situation slightly different from the norm is that he actually feels responsible for causing Talbot’s death. He has taken it upon himself that if he had left Talbot on the battlefield and brought the doctor’s to him he may have lived. So an overall great book from Cecilia Grant, I can’t wait to read her third book, A Woman Entangled, which involves another Blackshear sibling.
Do You like book A Gentleman Undone. Cecilia Grant (2012)?
It's well written but a rather heavy and bleak story - not quite my cup of 'escapism' tea.
—laurie
More mesmerizing writing. Sympathetic personalities wrestling with impossible situations.
—Ryan
Splendid story, beautifully written. I enjoyed every word.
—Csegaan
